Best Mattresses of 2016 and Worst-Rated Beds to Skip

Best Mattresses of 2016 and Worst-Rated Beds to Skip

Best Memory Foam Mattresses of 2016

Are you wondering which are the best mattresses of 2016? This is the place to learn how to find the best and avoid the worst mattresses. We compare innerspring and memory foam beds from some of the top names in the industry like Serta, Sealy, Tempurpedic and more to see how they stand up. Pay attention, we rate the best memory foam mattresses and innerspring mattresses of the year.

Innerspring and memory foam mattresses are purchased the most often, though memory foam tends to receive better overall owner satisfaction rates. In the next sections we review the 10 best mattresses of 2016

5 Best Memory Foam Mattresses

MattressSpecsWarranty / ReturnsOwner Satisfaction
Amerisleep Revere BedMed-firm
12” profile
3” 4.0 lb memory foam
9” 1.65 lb foam base
20 years
100 days
The Leesa MattressMedium
10” profile
4” 3.3 lb memory foam
6” 1.8 lb foam base
10 years
100 days
Sleep Innovations 14 InchMed-firm
2.5” 3.0 lb memory foam
2.5” foam
9” foam base
20 years
Depends on retailer
Tempurpedic Contour Rhapsody BreezeMed-firm
12” profile
1.2” 7.0 lb memory foam
2.8” 4.0 lb memory foam
8” foam
10 years
90 days
Signature Sleep 12” Memoir FoamMed-firm
4” 4.0 lb memory foam
8” foam base
1 year
30 days (Amazon)
90 days (Wal-Mart)

Data for the 5 Best Memory Foam Mattresses from independent review site or individual retail sites.

#1. Amerisleep Revere Bedbest memory foam mattresses of 2016

Amerisleep is a newer mattress company that offers plant-based memory foam mattresses. The Revere Bed is their most popular bed and one of the best memory foam mattresses available. Made from healthy, natural materials, Amerisleep mattresses are also covered in Celliant-infused fabric. This thermoreactive material has been clinically proven to improve circulation, reduce pain and has many other health benefits.

Amerisleep mattresses are available online and they offer a risk-free trial period. You can try any mattress for 100 nights in your home to make sure you like it.

#2. The Leesa Mattress

Another newer company, Leesa, offers only one mattress. Several new companies are following this route hoping it will pay off. Side sleepers may find the Leesa mattress too firm, as others have. Leesa claims to have created a mattress with “universal appeal,” but a few of their customers would disagree. Still, this is a good bed for the price, though it may not be suitable for long-term regular use. This mattress is available at

#3. Sleep Innovations 14 Inch

Sleep Innovations mattresses are available online at Amazon and Costco. This mattress is best for people who don’t sleep on their sides and are looking for a mattress with a taller profile. This is one of the top mattresses in the lower price range. The Sleep Innovations 14 Inch receives good customer reviews, but does have above average reports of odors or offgassing being a significant problem.

#4. Tempurpedic Contour Rhapsody Breeze

The Contour Rhapsody Breeze from Tempurpedic is one of their most popular beds. It receives lower than average ratings for being on the higher end of the price scale, but is made to last awhile. You can expect good pain relief, but it may also have an odor according to some customer reviews.

#5. Signature Sleep 12” Memoir Foam

The 12” Memoir Foam mattress is one of the best memory foam mattresses for the money. It is not made from high-quality ingredients and won’t stand up long to regular use, but it does receive good reviews in the short term. If you are looking for a cheaper guest bed or another bed that will be used infrequently, the Memoir is a good choice. You can find Signature Sleep mattresses at Wal-Mart, Amazon and Sears.

5 Best Innerspring Mattresses

MattressSpecsWarranty / ReturnsOwner Satisfaction
Sealy Posturepedic Grant Park Cushion Firm Tight TopFirm
12.5” profile
2.5” polyester
.5” gel foam
704 pocket coils
Depends on retailer80%
Serta iSeries Vantage PlushPlush
13” profile
.75” gel memory foam
1.0” foam
1008 duet pocket coils
10 years
120 days
Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare FirmFirm
10” profile
?” foam
800 pocket coils
10 years
Depends on retailer
Stearns and Foster Lily-Rose 13.5” Luxury PlushPlush
13.5” profile
2” gel foam
.5” foam`
? pocket coils
10 years
Depends on retailer
Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice FirmFirm
10” profile
1.5” 1.8 lb foam
1” foam
1.5” 1.8 lb foam
750 pocket coils
15 years
120 days

Data for the 5 Best Innerspring Mattresses is from independent review site or individual retail sites.

#1. Sealy Posturepedic Grant Park Cushion Firm Tight Top

The highest rated innerspring in our review, the Grant Park Cushion Firm Tight Top is one of Sealy’s more moderately priced beds. Sealy is no stranger to the mattress industry and you can expect their level of quality in this innerspring bed, though you’ll pay more for it. The gel core is designed to keep you cool through the night and the encased coils provide great motion isolation for an innerspring. Sealy mattresses are available through various retailers and online.

#2. Serta iSeries Vantage Plush

This mid-priced innerspring has above average owner satisfaction ratings for an innerspring. More iSeries Vantage owners report issues with odors and offgassing than owners of Serta Perfect Sleeper lines do. Gel memory foam is used in the comfort layer to help the mattress keep a cool feel. The Duet pocketed coils are actually two coils, one set inside the other. This adds to support and durability of the mattress.

#3. Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Shakespeare Firm

This lower-priced bed offers good support and comfort for the money. Durability is the major complaint, with body impressions and premature sagging being cited often. This mattress may be best used infrequently. Knowing this you can get what you need from the BeautyRest Shakespeare. Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are widely available online and in stores.

#4. Stearns and Foster Lily-Rose 13.5” Luxury Plush

Stearns & Foster is known for for creating a luxurious appearance and are mid-to high priced depending on the model. The Lily-Rose is in the upper middle on the innerspring price scale. Two inches of gel foam make up the comfort layer to help you sleep comfortably. Durability and lifespan are typical complaints for Stearns & Foster beds and the Lily-Rose is no different. Innersprings in general have poor longevity.

#5. Denver Mattress Doctor’s Choice Firm

Denver Mattress touts their high-density foam as a selling point for the Doctor’s Choice, a bed on the lower end of the pricing scale. Don’t expect this to be one of the best memory foam mattresses, as noise and durability are a couple common complaints for owners of this bed. Under limited use, the Doctor’s Choice is more likely to meet a consumer’s expectations. Denver Mattress has a 120 day return policy, which is longer than most retailers.

Worst-Rated Beds to Skip

#1. Overpriced Mattresses

Many beds are priced much higher than the value they offer consumers. Price is one of those factors that can affect a consumer’s perception of other factors. If you pay more for a bed, you expect more longevity, durability and comfort among other things. One of the main reasons some beds are overpriced is advertising. Big brands have to spend a lot of money on advertising and they pass those costs onto customers.

#2. Promotional Beds

Sometimes called “doorbusters” for their prices so low, customers will break the doors down trying to get to them. These are usually only sold for a limited time and are sometimes even made specifically with sales events in mind. This makes it difficult to find information or reviews of the mattress. The best memory foam mattresses will be advertised year round. 

#3. Really Cheap Beds

Unless you are shopping for a temporary or limited-use bed, avoid mattresses that are on the very bottom of the price scales. The bed may have good reviews, but very likely will not stand the test of time. Be wary of beds that are less than $500 for a queen.

#4. Thin Mattresses

Beds that are too thin present some problems. If you are heavier or a side sleeper, you likely will find there isn’t enough bed there for you. Larger people and side sleepers put more pressure on the bed. This can compress the upper layers of a mattress to a point of no longer providing cushioning support. Even the best memory foam mattresses cannot support you with a few inches of material. 

#5. Hot Memory Foam

One of the most common problems with memory foams is sleeping hot. Plant-based foams have got this problem covered, but traditional petroleum-based foams and gels still have many complaints of heat retention. You don’t have to buy the best memory foam mattresses, but, take a look at consumer complaints about heat retention to make sure you don’t get stuck in a hot bed. 

#6. Low-Density Memory Foam

Lower-density foams will not last as long as those of higher densities. High-density memory foam is more expensive, but you get what you pay for. The best memory foam mattresses tend to have medium to higher-density foams (generally 3.5 lb per cubic foot and higher). Check the foam densities of the beds you are thinking about buying.  If a retailer is not up front with the details, that is probably a bad sign.

#7. Mattresses with Poor Warranties

This probably goes without saying, but certainly check the warranty before you commit to a purchase. Read the fine print and make sure you understand it. A mattress warranty should be at least 10 years long. If a company can’t stand by their product, should you?

#8. Beds with No Return or Exchange Policy

This is another fairly obvious point, but it should be stated. Understand the return policy of the company you are ordering from before you buy. You don’t want to be stuck with a bed that doesn’t fit your frame, or is uncomfortable.

#9. Too Soft or Too Firm Beds

Firmness is subjective, that is, up to the individual. One person’s plush may be another’s medium firm. Make sure you get to know the feel of your mattress and if it isn’t for you, send it back. Showroom mattresses are often not the same firmness as the models they are intended to represent. Keep in mind, you may need a few weeks to get used to a new sleeping surface.

#10. Beds with No Motion Isolation

If you are sleeping with a partner or pet in the bed, motion isolation is an especially important feature of a good mattress. Innerspring mattresses are nowhere near as solid as memory foam and latex beds in this regard. Spring beds with pocketed coils do perform better than those without, but still lack considerably. Make sure you can sleep with the amount of motion isolation your mattress provides, literally.

Finding the Best Memory Foam Mattresses

Whether your seeking the best memory foam mattresses or any type of bed, getting a new bed is an exciting thing. If you get one you love, it is worth all the trouble. When mattress shopping take your time look into the specifics. The highest rated beds may be too expensive or not suitable for your needs. Think about what you need and stay within your budget. You don’t want to rush or you may miss the best mattresses of 2016.